Pluchinsky and Gaffney had two-round totals of 144. Pluchinsky had a pair of 72s while Gaffney carded a 71 on Tuesday following a round of 73 on Monday.
The Penguins finished with a two-round total of 584 with a 293 on Monday and a 291 on Tuesday. Western Kentucky won with a 566 while Cleveland State was second, Evansville and Robert Morris tied for third and Bradley was fifth.
This was the final tournament of the fall for the Penguins.